Saturday 11th November 2006

[Omega]

Well you could have knocked me over with a feather in tonights results :bigeyes:

I think it is becoming a little bit political between the Judges; it's about time the ditched Louis in my opinion :P

What a position to put Simon in, but I do think he has made the best choice to keep Ray in :thumbs:

Eton Road were not as good as they were last week, but I love them anyway

The Big Macs - well what a surprise tonight they were very good

Leona - First Class singer

Ben - not keen on him not my type

Robert was fantastic


But I will be a bit cynical that it was not gonna be that Simon would keep 3 acts in so one of his had to go again tonight - I think the winner is already sorted out :rolleyes:

[Annabel]

very harsh tonight, neither ray or nikitta were as bad as eton road (who were so camp they were off the scale ) or the macdonald brothers. ok the mac bros did ok tonite but overall they have been quite weak and certainly weaker than nikitta. damn shame she had to go.

Leona and robert were great tonight!

[sp54]

I thought Nikitta was by far the weakest the last 2 weeks so she deserved to go.

Leona is getting better and better - she could go all the way :unsure:

Love Ben :thumbs: and Eton Road, even though their performance wasn't their best tonight.

[mazza]

Yeah, I am bored of the Ray 'swing and cheesy grin' thing now :yawn:.

If Sharon and Louis were smart, they would have both voted Ray off as he is a bigger threat than Nikitta...I did like Nikitta and was willing her to do well, but in the end I just don't think she was ready for it.

I am having trouble liking any of them enough at all this year.... :rolleyes: I guess technically Leona is very good and really does have the ability to do well, but for me she isn't really my cup of tea and she really does need to watch her lip quivering and warbling! :lol:

[Matthew]

Great shows tonight! B)

Did anyone see the Xtra Factor where Sharon absolutely toyed with Simon? Classic stuff - hilarious, I thought Simon was going to have a mega-strop! :o Was Sharon tipsy?! :drunk:

I'm really pleased for Robert (who I voted for) staying in after that brilliant performance and an awful last week.

Leona was again superb, with Ben (who had my 2nd vote) putting in a good show too.

I have warmed a lot to the Eton Road lads and their performances, although I didn't think this week's was as good, but I think they seem to be a genuine group of guys who are quite likeable (surprises me as they're not my cup of tea to be honest!). :xfactor:

Nikita could have done a lot better perhaps - just didn't quite get the right song, the right choice - but handled herself with dignity on losing and I thought her last performance was much better (such a shame she was a little out of tune and her intonation wasn't quite there in places).

Ray was good too - I'd like to see him do something different too....but hey, if Chico can last as long as he did last year, why not Ray?!

McDonald brothers - I really liked these two in the auditions, etc - but they've almost been nerve-wracking to watch at times, but tonight was so much better.

Looking forward to seeing next week's. :)

[Eeyore]

We thought Sharon was drunk as well, Simon looked so hacked off and I tthought she was going to take his clothes off the way she was going on :lol:

Who is keeping those MacDonalds brothers in, they are dire dire dire - and this is a singing contest, they're like a bad act at a karaoke :(

I like Ray, and I'm sick of hearing Louis say he was a one trick pony, Eminem does rap, do you wanna hear him do Country and western? Or Sinatra do rock? Kylie singing garage - everyone who is successful in the music industry has something about them that they do well, take Kylie, she does great pop, and it's made her successful, G4 who do their kind of stuff well, so why can't Ray stick with swing which he does so so well, I watch him perform and it makes me feel really good and happy - and that to me is the X-factor

As for Louis rattling about one trick ponies, what does he do? Oh yes, manage boy bands that all sound the same

[mazza]

:lol: I saw the extra factor bit and I am amazed that Simon did not rise to Sharon's bait - it was really funny, she had me squirming with what she was doing to him! :hihi:

[tortoise]

Ben - Like him, but I'm not sure he could win as his voice is very distinctive.

Nikitta - Liked her, but she always sounded out of tune.

Mc Donald Bros - Don't like them at all.

Leonne - Good voice, but would like to see her sing something a little more upbeat.

Eton Road - Love them, but didn't like Antonys bit in the middle last night.

Ray - Good at what he does, but he gets on my nerves a bit. Good redition of Michael Bubles "Crazy little thing called love"

Robert - Wow. He was excellent last night. Glad he wasn't in the bottom two.

I would like to see Robert or Eton Road go all the way.